Can a No-Tech Aquarium Be Successful? My Experiment

Can a No-Tech Aquarium Be Successful? My Experiment

How the Experiment Started – The Father Fish Method

After years of experimenting with different lighting, substrates, fish, and plants in my larger aquariums, I decided to try something completely different – a no-tech aquarium following the "Father Fish" method. My goal was simple: to see if nature could maintain balance without the usual filtration, CO₂, or heaters.

I took a minimalist and budget-friendly approach:

  • Substrate: Regular plant soil from a supermarket – around 10 EUR for two bags.
  • Cap layer: Fine quartz sand to prevent excessive nutrient release.
  • Lighting: A basic LED strip with a dimmer from a local hardware store.
  • Background: Simple black foil for depth.
  • Plants: Fast-growing species from a trusted aquarist.

The aquarium was set up in just a few hours. I filled it with water and let it sit for about a day before planting (I can’t recall if I planted immediately or on the second day). Everything seemed fine… at first.

The First Challenges – When the “Natural Balance” Fails

In the first few days, I noticed typical issues with no-tech aquariums:

  • No water circulation – The water was completely still, creating stagnant areas.
  • Cloudy water – Expected when using soil, but it gradually cleared up.
  • Plant adaptation – Without CO₂ and filtration, plants had to adjust on their own.

Then something unexpected happened:

The plants suddenly grew extremely fast, reaching above the surface. However, at the same time, the lower parts started rotting and losing leaves. This imbalance triggered new problems:

  • String algae explosion – Likely due to excess nutrients from the soil.
  • I introduced snails and shrimp – Hoping they would help control the algae.
  • Planaria appeared – A common issue in tanks with rich organic matter.

To deal with the planaria, I used a special treatment. That’s when the biggest shift occurred – the tank's nitrogen cycle crashed.

  • The shrimp and snails disappeared – Possibly due to the treatment, lack of oxygen, or another unknown factor.
  • I started larger water changes – Every 2-3 days to try and stabilize the tank.
  • Nitrogen cycle reset – Suddenly, ammonia and nitrites spiked, showing that beneficial bacteria had been affected.

At this point, I realized that while I was aiming for a self-sustaining system, my interventions were actually disrupting the balance.

What Worked Well?

  • Fast-growing plants absorbed excess nutrients and helped stabilize the tank.
  • The soil acted as a powerful biological filter, supporting beneficial bacteria.
  • The LED strip lighting was sufficient for low-tech plant growth.

What Didn’t Work?

  • Plants grew unevenly – Their rapid growth above the surface led to decay below.
  • Algae became uncontrollable when balance was lost.
  • Planaria, snails, and shrimp introduced unexpected dynamics.
  • The planaria treatment disrupted the nitrogen cycle, leading to a crash.

Final Verdict – Was the Experiment a Success?

Yes and no.

  • A no-tech aquarium can work, but only with the right plants and a stable environment.
  • Had I left it alone instead of interfering, things might have naturally balanced out.

🚨 But the experiment also revealed key weaknesses of this approach:

  • Lack of circulation and controlled organic decomposition can lead to serious issues.
  • At some point, external intervention becomes necessary.

If You Want to Try a No-Tech Aquarium, Here’s My Advice:

  • Choose a mix of fast and slow-growing plants – Don’t rely only on fast growers.
  • Make gradual changes – Avoid sudden interventions like treatments or large water changes.
  • Be mindful of organics – Soil is nutrient-rich, which can cause problems if not managed properly.

📌 Have you ever tried a no-tech aquarium? Share your experience in the comments!

Back to blog

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.